Apparent Planetary Magnitudes

Amateur and professional astronomers know that the apparent brightness, or magnitude (V), varies greatly from planet to planet. For example, Venus is high in the morning sky at twilight at this time in its orbit. It is very bright. It has a large apparent magnitude. Neptune has a very low apparent magnitude due to its distance from the Sun. Most people have no idea where to look for it and have never seen it.

This chart is in Computing Apparent Planetary magnitudes for The Astronomical Almanac authored by Anthony Mallama and James L. Hilton of the US Naval Observatory in June 2018. It is an attractive display of the apparent magnitudes of the planets as seen from Earth. Not only is it artistic, there is a lot of science to see if we examine the details contributed by each planet.

A. Mallama,  J. Hilton | USNO

What is Magnitude?

Magnitude in astronomy refers to the brightness of an object. It is believed by many that Hipparchus (c. 190 – c. 120 bc) ranked the stars on a scale of apparent brightness from 1 being the brightest and 6 the dimmest to the eyes. Ptolemy used that system in 150 AD.

Norman Robert Pogson (1829 – 1891) was an English astronomer who worked in India at the Madras Observatory. He proposed that 1st magnitude stars were 100 times brighter than 6th magnitude stars. Each magnitude change was then on a logarithmic scale of 5√100 ≈ 2.512 times. A 5th magnitude star was 2.512 times brighter than a 6th. A 1st was 2.512 x 2.512 times brighter than a 3rd, and so on.  This is the magnitude system used today. Modern instruments allow seeing objects much dimmer than 6th magnitude. They would be set at the far right of this scale. Venus can reach brightness of -5. The Moon can be -13 when full. Our Sun sits at magnitude -27 far off the left end of this scale. This link shows other examples.

Apparent Magnitudes of the Planets

Consider the orbits of the outer gas giant planets. Earth’s orbit is the small innermost circle in the following diagram. The radius of our orbit from the Sun is called 1 Astronomical Unit of distance, or 1 AU. The gas planets are much farther from the Sun. Neptune = 30.0 AU. Uranus = 19.2 AU. Saturn = 9.6 AU. Jupiter = 5.2 AU. We see the full sunlit side of each planet because they are so far away. The farther the planet is from the Sun, the dimmer it appears to us. Jupiter appears at about magnitude -3 and Neptune at about magnitude +8.

Neptune

Our view of Neptune from Earth is always close to 30 AU. Earth orbits much faster than Neptune. During part of our orbit we are only 29 AU from Neptune while we are 31 AU away 6 months later. That is barely 6% difference in distance. The change in brightness of Neptune due to that small distance change is not noticeable to the eye. Sensitive instruments could detect it.

Suppose the apparent magnitude of Neptune was observed from Earth for 50 years and plotted often. The next diagram is how the magnitude would vary according to Anthony Mallama and James L. Hilton of the US Naval Observatory. The vertical scale has dimmest at the bottom and brightest at the top. The magnitude of Neptune varies only slightly on the vertical scale due to Earth being slightly closer and farther from Neptune as we orbit the Sun.

Elongation is along the horizontal axis. It refers to the alignment of the planet to the Sun as seen from Earth. If the planet is in the opposite direction from the Sun as seen from Earth, the elongation is 180˚. It is seen as high points on this graph. Remember, high axis values mean brighter magnitudes. At this opposition time, the Earth is as close as possible in its orbit to the planet Neptune.

Elongation of 0˚ means Neptune is in the same direction as the Sun. It is called conjunction. That puts the Earth farthest away from Neptune as is possible. The brightness of Neptune is at its lowest values. Because Neptune is very far away and our orbit doesn’t change that distance by much, its apparent magnitude varies only a small amount.

Uranus

Similar arguments hold true for the magnitude of Uranus if observed during a 50 year period. It is 19.2 AU from the Sun. As Earth orbits at 1 AU, the distance to Uranus varies from 18.2 to 20.2 AU. That is a slightly larger percentage than for Neptune. The values of magnitude are in the range of 5.6 compared to 7.8 for Neptune meaning Uranus it is a brighter planet.

Saturn

The apparent magnitude of Saturn is also affected by the orbital distance of Earth and by the elongation of Saturn with respect to the Sun. We are significantly closer to Saturn than Uranus or Neptune. Saturn has an orbit of 9.6 AU. Earth’s orbit distance changes our distance to Saturn from 8.6 to 10.6 AU making its magnitude a little more than 1.

The tilt of the ring system is another significant effect impacting the apparent magnitude of Saturn. When seen edge on, the rings are practically invisible and reflect no sunlight to Earth. We only see light from the globe of the planet. When the rings are at maximum tilt, we see more reflected light from Saturn. That tilting rings effect is shown in the first 90 sec of this video.

The changing tilt of the rings causes a large difference in magnitude of the planet as viewed from Earth. It causes the width of the band in the diagram below to be rather wide.

Another curious effect appears in this graph at elongation of 0˚ when the Sun and Saturn are nearly aligned as seen from Earth. The planet would normally be at its most dim when far from Earth in that alignment due to the larger distance. But light reflected back from the planet creates a surge in brightness close to that alignment. It may to be caused by increased exposure of the ice crystals in the rings. Another smaller surge is seen at opposition elongation of 180˚. This opposition surge is a similar effect to seeing a glory in the atmosphere.

Jupiter

Being about half the distance as Saturn, Jupiter orbits 5.2 AU from the Sun. Earth’s orbit changes our distance from Jupiter between 4.2 and 6.2 AU causing a substantial change in magnitude. It has no significant ring system and also shows no signs of a surge in brightness at 0˚ or 180˚.

Orbits of Terrestrial Planets

Mars

This planet orbits about one third as far from the Sun as Jupiter. Mars orbits at an average of 1.5 AU. Earth’s orbit changes our distance from Mars between about 0.5 and 2.5 AU. This big variation causes the brightness of Mars to vary over a wide range of several orders of magnitude. In addition, seasonal changes on Mars create polar caps which change the brightness of reflected light to the Earth. Dust storms can also have a similar small effect.

Mars is positioned with respect to Earth in three general ways as it orbits the Sun. Here we see it from the side as illustrated by this top view. In this perspective, we don’t see the fully illuminated face of Mars. It appears more like a waxing or waning moon. That decreases its apparent magnitude.

We can also see Mars relatively close to Earth in this orbit position. This is called opposition when elongation is 180˚.  It appears largest and brightest during this time.

We see Mars farthest away when it appears aligned with the Sun during conjunction. It appears smallest and dimmest during this time.

Because of these widely different perspectives, the apparent magnitude varies a lot over time. There even exists a small surge in brightness depicted in the chart at 0˚ during conjunction.

Venus

Since the orbit of Venus is closer to the Sun than that of Earth, we never see it venture very far from the Sun. There is a limit to its elongation of about 45˚ as depicted in this orbit diagram. As with Mars, we don’t see the fully illuminated face of Venus when it is in this position. It appears as a crescent affecting its apparent magnitude.

Venus is positioned closest to Earth during this part of its orbit depicted below. It orbits the Sun faster than Earth and passes us. This is known as inferior conjunction. From our Earth point of view, the opposite side of Venus is illuminated thus causing the planet to appear much less bright. We see a thin crescent of the planet.

This image by Thierry Legault captures Venus only 2.4˚ from the Sun. Gases in the atmosphere allow a ring of light to be seen with Venus in silhouette.

When Venus travels to the opposite side of its orbit and aligns again with the Sun from our view, this is called superior conjunction. We gradually see more of its fully illuminated face. But, it is also much father away resulting in an apparent magnitude of a nearly constant value during the weeks of superior conjunction.

Combining these effects of distance and phase angles gives us this interesting magnitude chart. The bumps at about 10˚ elongation are due to the gases allowing a ring as seen in the Legault image above.

Mercury

Last, but certainly not least, is the diagram of apparent magnitude for Mercury. Being the closest to the Sun of all the planets, it never wanders far. It is never seen more than 28˚ on either side of the Sun. And, it orbits quickly in 88 days. It presents phases toward Earth and the distance varies as it and Earth orbit. Diagrams are similar to those of Venus with respect to Earth except Mercury has a smaller orbit than Venus.

Mercury orbits at 0.4 AU from the Sun. Seen from Earth, Mercury varies in distance from us between 0.6 and 1.4 AU. The resulting diagram of magnitude versus elongation over a 50 year period of time has a unique shape and covers several orders of magnitude. Most people have never viewed Mercury even though it is a very bright object at times. One must look just after sunset, or just before sunrise, in order to see Mercury.

During inferior conjunction, Mercury is closest to Earth and aligned with the Sun. We don’t see the illuminated face of the planet. It has a very dim magnitude, if it is visible at all in the Sun’s glare. At superior conjunction, Mercury is farthest from Earth and again aligned with the Sun. We see the fully illuminated face at its brightest.

Summary

What generalizations can be made about the apparent magnitudes of the planets?

  • Venus by far has the largest apparent magnitude between -4 and -5.
  • Mercury has the biggest range of magnitude from 5 to nearly -3.
  • Jupiter is consistently between -2 and -3 in brightness.
  • Mars appears between magnitudes of -2 and +2.
  • Mercury and Mars have the biggest ranges of magnitude of all the planets.
  • Saturn has a large range of magnitude mainly due to the tilt of the ring system.
  • Uranus and Neptune show very little change in magnitude because they are far away.

11 thoughts on “Apparent Planetary Magnitudes

  1. I understand how the graphics show the variation in magnitude (and they are very beautiful and helpful!), but I am lost as to why the brighter planets get values with minus signs. Can you explain please?

    • Blame Hipparchus for that. He started it all by saying the brightest stars were 1 and the dimmest were 6. That convention has been carried forth through the ages. It is called a reverse logarithmic scale.

  2. That’s really intriguing information, Jim. Well researched.

    I’m familiar with the motions of the planets but did not expect such exotic curves for Mercury and Venus, nor did I anticipate the various dips and bumps.

    Also, it’s odd that Hipparchus did not include the brightness of the planets in his logarithmic scale. Didn’t they believe that planets were just wandering stars?

    • Thanks, it took a long time to get that post to a point where I felt it was ready to publish. I kept rereading and editing sentences. I learned a lot.

      I had always heard that planets were thought of as wandering stars. In my reading, it seems the magnitudes originally referred to their sizes, not brightness. It wasn’t until later that brightness became the standard.

  3. Much better than my college astronomy text, but that was more than 50 years ago. Thought that chart might be inspired by Georgia O’Keeffe.

    • I can see why you likened it to an O’Keefe. It caught my eye the first time I saw it. I had to know why the patterns looked that way.

  4. Very interesting post. The graphs do explain a lot. The plotting of Venus reminded me of a medical drawing of Ovaries. So it was Hipparchus that gave us that backwards scale. Also interesting to note Saturn’s brightest vary depending on the tilt of its rings. Thanks for the post. Like I said, I always learn new things from your posts. Take care.

    • Thank you. I had to think that post over for quite a long time. Lots of things were new to me.

      I’ve been watching Venus each clear morning. It is diving rapidly toward the Sun.

      Thanks for the link. I must have missed it before.

I'd like to hear from you.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.