Update | Planets Orbiting Other Stars


The sizes of more than 3/4 of the 3,500 candidate planets found by NASA’s Kepler spacecraft are between that of Earth and Neptune, 4x the size of Earth. Circled in this image are the many planet candidates found by Kepler as of January 2014. It is not known how they form or if they are made of rock, water or gas. Ground based telescopes are used to follow-up on the Kepler candidates and confirm their existence along with other important details about them. The Kepler team reported on these follow-up planets this week at the American Astronomical Society meeting in Washington.

Follow-up observations use Doppler measurements of the planets’ host stars as they wobble. The wobble is caused by the gravitational pull on the star by the orbiting planet. The wobble tells the mass of the planet. More wobble means a more massive planet. Imagine swinging a bucket around you as you spin in a circle. More water in the bucket would make you wobble more. Scientists at W. M. Keck Observatory in Hawaii confirmed 41 of the exoplanets discovered by Kepler and were able to calculate the masses of 16. Knowing mass and diameter, density could be calculated. They could then characterizing the planets as rocky or gaseous, or mixtures of the two.


Most of the planets in our solar system do not fit into this range of sizes. Astronomers wonder why. What evolution of our solar system caused a different outcome than the large population seen elsewhere in the galaxy?

“Kepler’s primary objective is to determine the prevalence of planets of varying sizes and orbits. Of particular interest to the search for life is the prevalence of Earth-sized planets in the habitable zone,” said Natalie Batalha, Kepler mission scientist at NASA’s Ames Research Center in Moffett Field, Calif. “But the question in the back of our minds is: are all planets the size of Earth rocky? Might some be scaled-down versions of icy Neptunes or steamy water worlds? What fraction are recognizable as kin of our rocky, terrestrial globe?”

As Previously Posted:

Our Sun has a multitude of objects in orbit around it. There are comets, asteroids, spacecraft, and planets. Do other stars also have planets? NASA’s Kepler spacecraft launched March 6, 2009 from Cape Canaveral Air Force Station in Florida. The first planet-hunting spacecraft set out on a mission to look for other planets around stars. Astronomers hoped to answer two questions.

  1. What fraction of the stars have planets in orbit around them?
  2. What fraction of those are in the habitable, or Goldilocks, zone where conditions are just right to possibly allow life to exist?

Based on ground telescopic views, large hot Jupiter-sized and large cold icy planets have already been observed around stars. Kepler is looking for those planets known as terrestrial, like Earth, that orbit at a distance that isn’t too hot or too cold. They tend to be smaller and more difficult to detect. A satellite spacecraft above our atmosphere is needed.

What Has Kepler Seen?

Kepler has stared at the same patch of sky for 3.5 yrs. The patch is small. Hold your hand out with your extended arm. That is how big the patch is. It contains 100,000 stars which were monitored continuously. If a planet in orbit around that star passed between the star and us, the level of brightness seen would decrease slightly. That is called a transit.

As of November 2013, Kepler found more than 3,500 potential planet candidates. About 200 have been confirmed. Click on a star named in the confirmation table at that link to see the details of the orbit and transit data. Interesting stuff. The candidates come in a variety of sizes around stars of different sizes. There are quite a few Earth sized candidates. But, fewer than 10 of those have had their data confirmed.


Based upon statistical analysis, most stars in the sky have planets. Furthermore, one in five stars like the Sun is home to a planet up to twice the size of Earth, orbiting in a temperate environment. Those are very encouraging numbers.

Kepler is Broken

The spacecraft launched with 4 small spinning gyroscope-like wheels attached to it. Changing the spin rate of these wheels allowed astronomers to keep the spacecraft pointed accurately at the field of 100,000 stars. Two of those reaction wheels have stopped working. The remaining two cannot keep the spacecraft pointed well enough. The mission is in danger of ending.

Recently, the astronomy team devised a work-around solution that should allow Kepler to resume studying stars. The reaction wheels were needed to counter-balance the effect of solar pressure on the spacecraft which tended to make it roll and point off target. The plan it to orient the spacecraft so the solar pressure is balanced on the ridge of the solar panel, seen in blue here and in the image at the top of this post. It is hoped the two remaining reaction wheels can maintain this alignment for 83 day stretches. Then, the spacecraft has to be repointed to prevent sunlight from entering the sensitive detector.

The plan has one serious tradeoff. It would no longer study the patch of stars it has been viewing for 3.5 yrs. A new patch would be in view each 83 days. But, it would be able to continue gathering data. The final funding decision is expected by the summer of 2014.

At this point in time, there remains over a year of original Kepler data that still needs to be reviewed and analyzed. With that, and the prospect of this new Kepler 2 mission, the spacecraft might still function well into the future. The list of Goldilocks planets will continue to grow.


11 thoughts on “Update | Planets Orbiting Other Stars

  1. Well isn’t the main problem with Kepler is how short it ran? Yes, we found a lot of “Earth-like” canidates in terms of size, and sure there is more data to look through. But all of these planets have to be close to their star, correct? Hopefully the next mission will be able to run longer so we can have more blips show up for more planets that could take longer (and hopefully match an orbital time that’s closer to Earth’s) to orbit their sun could be found and confirmed.

    Great post!

    • It ran three and a half years. Longer would have been better. The discovery rate was high for candidates.

      In the chart above, most of the candidates are showing orbit periods of less than 50 days. Mercury orbits in 88 days. The candidates are quite close as you said. They are much too close to provide the Goldilocks ‘just right’ conditions they hope to find. It is hoped the Kepler 2 revised mission will be approved so they can find those desired one.

      Thank you for stopping in and making your comments.

I'd like to hear from you.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.