Comet ISON | Dead? Alive? Next?

What a surprising comet this has been, even from the start when discovered in September 2012. It has defied predictions. It was hyped as the comet of the century. One thing is certain. It got a lot of attention and continues to surprise.

ISON plunged toward the sun gaining speed and brightness. During the hours before closest approach, or perihelion, it brightened, then dimmed and seemed to no longer have a tail. The highest resolution imagery during the closest approach distances by the SDO spacecraft didn’t show anything. It started to show a tail and increasing brightness as it departed. That was a surprise. This 15 sec video records the approach, perihelion, and departure. Replay it several times. Look for ISON to dim as it neared the Sun. Notice it is barely visible upon re-emergence. Then, it brightens considerably. The black disc in the center has an image of the Sun superimposed. The disc blocks the bright sunlight from entering the camera and obscuring the view.


Here are three frames for comparison as ISON departs the Sun. The comet appears to brighten. This puzzled astronomers. They thought it had been destroyed during the intense heat of the close pass. These images are from late Thursday night the 28th and early to midday Friday the 29th.

This next image is from very late Friday to early Saturday 30th UT. It appears to show ISON again dimmer. What is will do the next few days is not known.

One of the more informative articles about ISON came from Karl Battams at the U.S. Naval Research Laboratory in Washington, DC. He is an astrophysicist and computational scientist based in the solar physics group at NRL. Here is the link to his blog post late Thursday night after he had intensely followed ISON and tried to field questions and give reasonable answers. I offer a few quotes.

I’ll just say this upfront right now: whatever you read in the following blog post, please feel free to assume it is completely incorrect and the truth is actually quite contrary to what I’m saying. It has been – and continues to be – one of those days. So this will be a relatively brief blog post because we’re up to our necks in media inquiries and attempting to do real science to figure out the mystery that is comet ISON.

Right now, here’s our working hypothesis: As comet ISON plunged towards to the Sun, it began to fall apart, losing not giant fragments but at least a lot of reasonably sized chunks. There’s evidence of very large dust in the form of that long thin tail we saw in the LASCO C2 images. Then, as ISON plunged through the corona, it continued to fall apart and vaporize, and lost its coma and tail completely just like Lovejoy did in 2011. (We have our theories as to why it didn’t show up in the SDO images but that’s not our story to tell – the SDO team will do that.) Then, what emerged from the Sun was a small but perhaps somewhat coherent nucleus, that has resumed emitting dust and gas for at least the time being.

This has been fun to watch. Many of us have waited with high expectations for over a year wondering what it would do. It was exciting to watch the astronomy community come together and focus their attention with powerful instruments on the comet. It was great to have a wealth of internet tools available to all for watching the events unfold. I have also enjoyed sharing what I have found with readers. Someday, we will be blessed with another comet, or an eclipse, or something else unexpected. I can’t wait.


10 thoughts on “Comet ISON | Dead? Alive? Next?

  1. It has been fun. I read Battams’ piece when he posted it, and thought it a really nice summation of things to that point. Something else I read (who knows where?) is that the current “V” shape is due to a dust trail streaming toward the sun and ions streaming away. Is that right? In any event, “it” is still there – whatever “it” is!


    • Yes, the low mass gas molecules are ionized and follow magnetic field lines. They will be on a different path than the more massive dust grains.

      I haven’t looked yet at the latest images. Coffee comes first. It was a wild ride for the comet. It was going about 13% the speed of light.


  2. A nice re-cap, Jim! I’m sure you’re familiar with the quote on comets by David H. Levy — “Comets are like cats: they have tails, and they do precisely what they want.”

    Comet ISON proved this, over and over again! I agree with you completely about the excitement and infectiousness of getting together with the astronomy community around the world to share this event – and I can not wait for the next opportunity to do so! Battams was brilliant throughout, that he maintained his enthusiasm and sense of humor (and humanity!) while trying to do his job with countless thousands flinging questions was most impressive.


    • Thanks. That’s a good quote and exactly right. We’ve had our share of cats. Don’t try to herd them.

      We’ve had some phenomenal events recently with Curiosity, Higgs, ISON… These things live on in the lives of the people who experience them, especially the young. As a kid, I witnessed Sputnik, Gagarin, Glenn, failed rockets, then later, Voyagers, Viking, Apollo, Shuttles, the list is long. It gets in your blood.

      I look forward to more to come.


      • Will you be following the Chinese launch of Chang’e-3 early on Monday? I wrote about it previously, and will probably be following up on it – the first soft landing on the moon since the Soviet’s Luna 24 back in 1976.


      • No, I won’t be doing that. We need to get up just after 5 and go to breakfast. Our son is driving back to OK tomorrow with a class mate. They wanted breakfast before their 10 hr drive.

        Also, our future daughter-in-law heads to Ann Arbor with a class mate. That’s a 7 hr drive. So, we are all getting breakfast early at a restaurant next to I-80.

        They are all here now having some fun around the dining room table.

        I will look up your post and read it. What month was it?


  3. It will be interesting to see what happens with this comet. I don’t follow comets very closely but I have a general sense that there have been several comets in recent years to turned out to be “busts”.


    • ISON is probably going to fade into oblivion. But, as one of the astronomers pointed out, there is a wealth of data from multiple instruments that will be analyzed for years. That’s very good.

      Right. It happens often enough. When the media get a hold of the potential for a comet of the century, it really assures a hard letdown. Nothing ever lives up to the hype.

      The two best ones recently were Hale-Bopp and Hyakutake in 1997.


  4. This evening I saw an interview with former astronaut Gene Cernan, the last man to walk on the moon (41 years ago). He decried the withdrawal of the United States from programs as adventurous as the ones to the moon, and even from less adventurous ones.


I'd like to hear from you.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s